Skip to content
Home Education Foundation

Serving, promoting, defending and publishing for Christian and secular home educators in NZ and overseas.

Home Education Foundation

Serving, promoting, defending and publishing for Christian and secular home educators in NZ and overseas.

Samuel Blight’s submission

SUBMISSION OF SAMUEL BLIGHT ON THE SOCIAL SECURITY (BENEFIT CATEGORIES AND WORK FOCUS) AMENDMENT BILL TO THE SELECT COMMITTEE

About the Submitter
1. This submission is made by Samuel Blight in a personal capacity. I would like to appear before the Committee to speak to my submission, although I may be
unavailable due to being out of the country.
2. My wife and I home educate our six children. We do so for a wide variety of reasons. While home educated, they have a significant amount of social interaction
with others of all ages, including with children their own age. This year we have had an underlying theme of world cultures and we will be in Europe for two and a
half months over the Christmas period both building on that learning and visiting extended family and friends.
3. We are currently not in receipt of any benefits, including Working for Families.
4. I work for a Tertiary Education Organisation where I have held various roles including as a full time tutor. My wife is a linguist and my parents both had careers
as teachers in both state and private schools.

Background to Bill
5. This bill, along with other government policy, seems to be based on a genuine desire to encourage beneficiaries, in particular long term beneficiaries, to get back
to work.

Support for the Bill
6. It is the opinion of this submitter that large parts of the intent of this bill are valid and desirable. Benefits should be seen as a hand up and not a hand out. They should not be viewed as a lifestyle choice, to live off the taxpayer, but rather a safety net to help those unfortunate enough to need it.

Concerns about the Bill
7. My concerns around this bill centre around the use of the welfare system “to reinforce some important social norms…”.
8. Regardless of what “social norms” the government seeks to impose, the imposition of them sets a dangerous precedent. Wittingly, or unwittingly, this writes into
legislation a list of things by which a parent can be judged as responsible or irresponsible. It is not without irony that these “social norms” are introduced in the
explanatory note between sanctions for illegal use of drugs and having a warrant for arrest.
9. We live in a society which celebrates diversity in many shapes and forms. In particular, New Zealand is known for its wide acceptance of diverse cultures and
religions.
10. While the government has jurisdiction to ensure some things, including that children are not abused, it has no jurisdiction (other than self appointed) to either define or “reinforce” social norms. To attempt to do so is an encroachment on the rights of the citizens it claims to represent. This is especially true when the said “social norms” are defined in terms of participation in government funded and controlled programs. This is not to say that those programs are undesirable, but only that compulsory participation is an encroachment on the rights of individuals and parents.
11. Secondarily, in the opinion of this submitter, this government has no electoral mandate to legislate “social norms”. In 2008 the National Party campaigned heavily on ending what it termed “the nanny state”. In many ways the legislation of “social norms” goes further in that regard than many things which caused that label to stick to the Labour Government of the day. While acknowledging the Government’s manifesto and the Prime Minister’s Key Result Areas, there is a huge gulf between what a Government wants to achieve by way of participation in its social programs and enforcing participation.
12. Further to the overarching concerns already noted, each of the “social obligations” has associated issues.

Early Childhood Education
13. “take all reasonable steps to have their dependent child aged 3 years or over, enrolled in and attending early childhood education until they start school.”
14. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 26, Sentence 3 reads: “Parents have a prior right to choose the kind of education that shall be given to their
children.” By legislating a “social obligation” which forces a parent to choose between various state decided and registered options, this legislation is inconsistent
with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
15. While in many cases, early childhood education provides much needed learning opportunities, for whanau who embrace active learning as a lifestyle, children
benefit much from this learning in the context of family mentoring. It is violation of the rights of the parents for the Government to force them into a registered
program.

School Attendance
16. “take all reasonable steps to have their dependent child enrolled in and attending school…”
17. I have particular concern for those parents who have made the choice and commitment to home educate their children. I quote from a personal letter from the
Minister to myself on the 18th of October 2012 where she states: “However, it is fair to say that, in general, a beneficiary parent will not be able to home school their
child”.
18. Paragraph 14 regarding the inconsistency with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is relevant in its entirety
19. I accept that it should not be the norm for someone to home educate their child from age 5 through to 18 while in receipt of a benefit when they could be providing for their family through employment.
20. However, for those parents who are not in receipt of a benefit and make the commitment to home educate their children, they already pay twice for their
children’s education. Firstly through their taxes contributing towards Vote Education and secondly through financing the education of their own children.
21. Should someone in this situation find themselves out of a job, it is entirely unreasonable for their Unemployment Benefit to be halved while looking for another
job, just because they are home educating their children.
22. I have provided a copy of the letter mentioned in paragraph 17 as an attachment so the letter can be read in context. While it does provide a range of context, both it and the proposed Bill seem to have the assumption that home educating is undesirable (particularly for families in receipt of a benefit) and will impact on the
ability of the family to provide it’s own income.
23. Overall home education in New Zealand is of a high quality. I have had a number of educators from a range of tertiary institutions in New Zealand indicate that they jump at the chance to enroll home educated students and several say that they will encourage them to enroll a year younger than their state schooled counterparts.
24. Furthermore, the economic argument for putting children into school so that a parent or two can work is often flawed. In many cases, the tax paid by the parent is well outstripped by the cost of a state primary or secondary education.
25. Finally, it is my observation that very few parents whose principle income is a benefit choose to home educate their children. In particular the attitudes which lead to the inter-generational dependence which this Bill seeks to address are usually entirely opposite to those attitudes which leads one to home educate their children.
26. It is more usual that parents decide to home educate their children and then unforeseen changes occur which lead them into receiving state support. In the
case of two parent families home educating is not a barrier to re-employment. In the cases I have observed of a home educating family going from two parents with
one income to a single parent on a benefit, it has enabled the family to work though the situation in a supported way. While I have observed single parents staying on
the benefit until their children were in their late teens, all I have known have always afterwards gone on into employment.

Enrolling with a primary health care provider and up-to-date with the WellChild checks.
27. Firstly, I acknowledge that these programs have a significant range of benefits. However, forcing these “benefits” upon people is not democratic.
28. In my letter to the Minister, I acknowledged that while all of our children had undertaken the WellChild checks with the midwife while under her care, they had
not had them subsequently done with a doctor or other community providers.
29. In social settings, we regularly interact with medical professionals and we utilise the public health service on an as-needed basis. They have also had a range of
medical examinations including ear and eye tests. However, to require that if a parent is in receipt of a benefit that certain programs are completed is dictatorial
and undemocratic.
30. Again, there are two fundamental issues here. This first is the encroachment of Government on what should be family decisions. The second is the government
holding up a standard of that it considers “social norms” as a defacto standard of good parenting.
31. Finally, legislating these “social obligations” will do little to protect those children most at risk from abusive parents and unhealthy lifestyles. Such significant
encroachment on the public to deal with the problems of a minority is neither good policy nor good government.

Summary
32. I propose that the section of the bill which deals with “social norms” be dropped completely.
33. I further propose that if any part of it remains, that all parents are left with the right to home educate their children and choose whether to use an ECE or not.
34. Lastly I propose that the right of parents to choose the kind of education that shall be given to their children be formally acknowledged and protected.

Thank you for considering this submission. I would like to make an oral submission also, and look forward to appearing should I be in the country.

Attachment:

Paula Bennett’s letter to Samuel Blight 18 October 2012

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

For Updates on Craig’s brain cancer:

Updates on Craig’s health written by family https://hef.org.nz/about-us/craig-smiths-health and Craig’s diary: Diary of a Brain Tumour https://hef.org.nz/about-us/craig-smiths-health/craigs-diary/ Youtube videos: https://hef.org.nz/q-a-with-craig/

Bank account details

A number of people have asked for the Smith's bank account details to be put up on this website to make it easier to give a donation to cover medical costs: CS BE Smith 020 727 0838357 00 BNZ Thank you for your donations
View Barbara Smith's profile on LinkedIn

  • Home schooling in New Zealand
  • http://www.home-ed.vic.edu.au/2002/02/26/john-gatto-teacher-of-the-year-acceptance-speech/
  • Trademe

H/E with Special Needs

  • 3-step approach to treat autism
  • Aspergers Syndrome – Understanding and Educating
  • Autism
  • Autism web
  • Autism: academic instruction
  • Brain Balance Center
  • BrainSkills
  • Christian naturopath mother of autistic children shares info,
  • Communicating with an Autistic Child: A Parent’s Guide
  • Drug free Asperger
  • Gifted Children NZ
  • HSLDA-Struggling Learner
  • Learning Processes
  • Lifestyle help with autism
  • Making Up Lost Time In Literacy
  • Nathhan News
  • Natural child
  • Raising your spirited child
  • Real Special NZ
  • Regional Health School (MoE NZ)
  • Sensory Integration for the Child With Autism
  • Struggling Learner
  • Testing for Special Needs Children
  • VerasKidsNZ
  • Zane Education

HEF Email discussion Groups

  • .Christian Classical Home Educators (ccednet)
  • .Christian Home Educators (chednetnz)
  • .Diana Waring History Alive (dwha)
  • .Home Education Foundation (hefnetnz)
  • .TEACH-eForum
  • Facebook: CraigandBarbaraSmith
  • Facebook: Home Education Foundation
  • Facebook: Home Education in NZ

Help with Exemption Application

  • Contacts for personal help
  • Lesson Plans
  • NZcurriculum
  • Online exemption form
  • Resources/Links
  • Sandra Dodd: Curriculum
  • The Exemption
  • The New Zealand Curriculum Online
  • Unschooling exemption

Maths

  • All in one homeschool
  • Cool math – games
  • Futureschool
  • Living math
  • Math Games-Free Printable
  • Math Worksheets
  • Maths curriculum including resources posters..games etc
  • Maths-NZ
  • Multiplication
  • On line math learning
  • Xtramath

National blogs

  • 3 Kiwi Home Schoolers
  • 4 Kiwi Girls
  • Adventures in sideways living
  • Altariel
  • Ang the FLYing Kiwi
  • Bethany’s Stories
  • Blight, Samuel and Kim
  • Bumble bee wrangler
  • Catching the Magic
  • Charmagne Smith
  • Cynthia’s Notes
  • Dream For Three
  • Family Integrity blogspot
  • Family of Girls
  • Freedom and Dreams
  • General Blogs in NZ
  • Grow Mama
  • Harts at home
  • Hilldogg Visionary
  • Home Making With Heart
  • Home School Journal
  • Home Schooling Diary
  • Home Schooling in NZ
  • Homeschool Family Life
  • Homeschooling on board
  • Kate's blog
  • Kiwi Kids
  • Kiwi Mum of Five
  • Last in line (HE in NZ)
  • Laughing around the Globe
  • Mama Shaw
  • Mamma With a Mission
  • MandM
  • Many little blessings
  • Mazuran sailing
  • Mermaids purse
  • METTLE Weekly Newsletter
  • Most Tranquil
  • Normal Education
  • Nouthetic Studies
  • NZchildrensbookreviews
  • NZchildrensbookreviews
  • NZchildrensbookreviews
  • Outside Hollywood
  • Rabbits Nest
  • Radiant journey
  • Read, Learn and Shine
  • Roman Kids Home School
  • Roses 07
  • Rosie Boom
  • scaryman-13 years old
  • Section59 blogspot
  • Sherena-KuraKainga
  • Sima J
  • Single Parent Homeschooling
  • Smith Family blog
  • South Auckland Home Educators
  • The Pukeko Patch
  • The Purple Pirate Ship
  • The Right Reply
  • Unschooled kids
  • Us in a bus
  • Visionary Daughters
  • Watching Kereru
  • Water Colour Dreams
  • West Coast Home Educators
  • West Coast Home Educators
  • Wild Child 222
  • Women Abiding
  • Wonder-mints

National websites

  • Across
  • Bookish
  • Boom family
  • Carey College
  • CHECH using ACE
  • Christ in Education
  • Christian Education Services
  • Christian herbalist
  • Duffy Entrepreneurs Club
  • ERO
  • ESA NZ
  • Family Integrity
  • Geneva Books
  • HomeschoolingNZ
  • Issacharian
  • Learnex
  • Learning as Families – Hamilton
  • MoE statistics
  • MoE-homeschooling
  • New Zealand Home Education
  • Nouthetic Studies
  • Saturday School of Music
  • Scholarships for Home Educators
  • Singapore Maths
  • South Auckland Home Educators
  • The Broad Room
  • The New Zealand Curriculum Online
  • Writing Excellence NZ
  • Yr 1-10 Resources and NCEA 1-3

New Zealand

  • Basic Maori practices, protocols and New Zealand history
  • Careers New Zealand
  • Correspondence School
  • Culture
  • elocal
  • ESA NZ
  • Kiwi stories for Kiwi kids
  • Korero maori – for learners
  • MoE statistics
  • NZ Earthquakes
  • Songs in Maori
  • The New Zealand Curriculum Online
  • Tki – The Online Learning Centre
  • Why choose NZ: compare NZ/Singapore
  • Yr 1-10 Resources and NCEA 1-3

NZ Home Education Support Groups

  • Auckland Home Educators
  • Canterbury Home Educators
  • Dunedin Home Educators (Sheaf)
  • HE West Coast
  • Home school tuition
  • Manawatu Home Educators (MHE)
  • Meetup.com/Wellington-Unschoolers
  • Nelson Christian Home Educators
  • NZ Home Education Support Groups
  • Rodney-Hibiscus Coast
  • SHEAF Dunedin
  • The Home Educators Network – Hamilton
  • Twin City Home Educators
  • WaiCHE(Karakariki)
  • Wairarapa Home School Group
  • Wairarapa Homeschool
  • Wellington Home Educataors
  • West Coast Home Educators
  • Whangarei Home Educators

NZ-r-Online Encouragement for Home Educators

  • .Christian Classical Home Educators (ccednet)
  • .Christian Home Educators (chednetnz)
  • .Diana Waring History Alive (dwha)
  • .Home Education Foundation (hefnetnz)
  • .TEACH-eForum
  • Auckland – East (East Auckland Home Educators)
  • Auckland South Home Educators
  • Auckland unschoolers
  • CMandFriends-ANZ · Australians, New Zealanders-Down-Under
  • Designer Kids
  • Facebook : Te Anau Home Schoolers
  • Facebook: AS Homeschooling NZ
  • Facebook: ASD Homeschooling South Auckland
  • Facebook: Canterbury Home Education
  • Facebook: Far North Homeschoolers
  • Facebook: Gifted Homeschoolers NZ
  • Facebook: Gisbornehomeschoolgroup
  • Facebook: HamiltoNZ HomeEducation
  • Facebook: Harvest-Curric-Swap-New-Zealand
  • Facebook: HASCA – Homeschool Auckland Sport & Cultural Association
  • Facebook: Home Education Foundation
  • Facebook: Home Education in NZ
  • Facebook: HomeEducationNZ
  • Facebook: Homeschool-Outings-Auckland-Area
  • Facebook: Homeschoolednz
  • Facebook: Kapiti Homeschool Families
  • Facebook: Manawatu Home Educators
  • Facebook: NCHENZ
  • Facebook: NelsonHomeSchool
  • Facebook: NZ Homeschool Curriculum Sell/Trade/Swap
  • Facebook: NZ Homeschool Curriculum Sell/Trade/Swap
  • Facebook: NZHomeSchoolTechTalk
  • Facebook: Secular Home Education Discussions (SHED)
  • Facebook: SHEAF Dunedin
  • Facebook: SHENET (Shore Home Educators Network)
  • Facebook: Single Parent Home Education NZ
  • Facebook: Sth Taranaki Home Educators
  • Facebook: Trademe-Homeschoolers-Support-Group
  • Facebook: Unschooling NZ retreat/networking
  • Facebook: Waldorf Inspired Homeschool NZ
  • Facebook: West Auckland Natural Learners / Unschoolers
  • Franklin Homeschool Group
  • Frugal-Kiwis-In-Christ
  • Harvest – for new books
  • Harvest – for Second Hand material
  • HE Trading post – furniture, books, clothes and appliances.
  • Home School Holiday Accommodation/Home-swaps
  • Home Spun Learning
  • Homeschool-Outings-Auckland-Area
  • Horowhenua Home Educators
  • HS Free Thinkers NZ
  • Kapiti homeschoolers
  • Manukau Home School Support
  • NCHEofNZ
  • NZ Catholic Home Ed
  • NZ Home Ed using Cambridge
  • NZ Home Educators
  • NZ Home Educators (Political)
  • NZ homeschooling (Christian textbooks)
  • NZUnschoolers
  • Radial Unschoolers (RUA)
  • Sharing (Diana) Waring
  • Single parent homeschool NZ
  • Single Parent Homeschooling
  • Taught of the Lord
  • Taupo home school
  • TAURANGA treasure chest
  • TePuke support group
  • THEN-Waikato
  • Trademe MessageBoard Unschoolers / Homeschoolers Support Thread
  • Twin City
  • Wairarapa Home School Group
  • Wairarapa Homeschool
  • Waldorf Steiner at home in New Zealand
  • West Auckland Natural Learners / Unschoolers
  • WHSA-Wellington

oAustralian blogs

  • Every Bed of Roses
  • Homeschool Downunder-Charlotte Mason style
  • Otherways: Home Education Network Home Education in Victoria

oAustralian email discussion groups

  • Aussie homeschool
  • chooz · Classical Home-based Options in OZ
  • Christian Homeschooling in Australia
  • Homeschool Victoria
  • Melbourne homeschool excursions

oAustralian Websites

  • Always learning books
  • Anselm Study House
  • Aussie homeschool
  • Australia Homeschooling
  • Australian Christian Home Schooling
  • Australian-rockpoolhomeschool
  • Department of Education
  • EDNA
  • Home Education Association Inc
  • Home Education in Victoria
  • Home Education Resources for Australian & New Zealand Home Educators
  • Homeschool Australia
  • Homeschooling Supplies
  • Life Long Learning
  • National Home Education Camp
  • National Homeschool Network

oInternational blogs

  • Around the world
  • Be Ready Compass
  • Doug's Blog – Hot topics
  • Fallacy Detective
  • First Class Homeschool Ministries
  • Home Education in England: the politics
  • Home Schooling in Cyprus
  • Homeschool Nations
  • Homeschoolblogger
  • Preschoolers and Peace
  • Sheila in Germany
  • Tarry in South Africa
  • The Mango Times
  • The Rebelution
  • When readers write

oInternational websites

  • Beginning Home Schooling
  • Christian Filmmakers
  • Christian Logic
  • Considering Home Schooling
  • Currclick.com
  • Diana Waring Presents
  • Early learning – UK
  • Entrepreneurial Homeschool Fathers
  • Exodus Mandate
  • Family Reformation
  • First Class Homeschool Ministries
  • Fraser Institute
  • Free and frugal homeschooling
  • Hesfes
  • Home Educating Family Reviews
  • Home School Legal Defense
  • Home school world
  • Home Schooling in Sweden
  • Home Schooling Today
  • Home Service — UK
  • Homeschool Penpals
  • Homeschool World Forum
  • Homeschool World: Contests for Homeschoolers
  • Homeschool-corner
  • Homeschooling.about
  • John Taylor Gatto
  • John Taylor Gatto Speech
  • Ladies Against Feminism
  • Lesson Library
  • Modesty Survey
  • National Home Education Research Institute
  • Patrice Lewis
  • Preschoolers and Peace
  • Rainbow Resource Centre
  • Sandra Dodd: Curriculum
  • Show And Know
  • The Chalcedon Foundation
  • The home school channel TV
  • The Home School Mom
  • The Homeschool Magazine
  • Trivium Pursuit
  • Vision Forum
  • Vision Forum Ministries
  • Visionary Daughters
  • Wolsey Hall Oxford
  • You can Home School
  • You can Home School

Reading

  • 72 basic phonograms
  • All in one homeschool
  • Burt reading test
  • Free Kindle books
  • Free Reading A–Z Samples
  • Futureschool
  • Homespun Bookslueths
  • Learner's Library
  • LibriVox – free audiobooks
  • NZchildrensbookreviews
  • NZchildrensbookreviews
  • NZchildrensbookreviews
  • Online practice reading tests
  • Progressive phonics
  • Read, Learn and Shine
  • Readability tests
  • Reading/writing for boys

sForeign Languages

  • El Rincón Español – homeschool Spanish support

Smith Family Websites and Blogs

  • bookspoems
  • Charmagne’s new blog
  • Charmagne’s old blog
  • Essential Oils
  • Family Integrity
  • Issacharian
  • PD Woodcraft
  • PDWoodcraft Youtube
  • Rainbow Resource Center, Inc.

Teaching Reading

  • Futureschool
  • NZchildrensbookreviews

zFree Preschool games

  • Apples 4 the Teacher
  • BBC-UK
  • Fisher Price
  • Gamequarium
  • Kids aol
  • Learn 4 Good
  • Preschool Learning Online
  • Preschool science activities
  • Radacadabra

zFree Stuff on the Web

  • 200+ page anatomy colouring book
  • 72 basic phonograms
  • All in one homeschool
  • Ambleside Primary
  • American History
  • Anatomy colouring book
  • Ancient History
  • Basic Maori practices, protocols and New Zealand history
  • books on line
  • Books, ebooks and audiobooks
  • Calendar-children make their own includes stickers
  • Childtopia
  • Christian Homeschool Bible Study
  • Class Room
  • Climate-NASA
  • Coloring book pictures, crafts and photos-printable
  • Craft workshop
  • Custom Writing Paper
  • DIY
  • E Learning
  • Early Learning
  • Early learning – UK
  • Educational videos
  • Engaging Science
  • Free books
  • Free Curriculum
  • FREE downloadable Swimming lesson plans (NZ MADE)
  • Free Harmonica Lessons
  • Free Kindle books
  • Free online classes
  • Free Paper Toys, Paper Models and Paper Crafts
  • Free Printable Flash Card Maker
  • FREE Sky Maps Each Month
  • Free Stuff For Homeschoolers
  • Free Thematic Units and Activity eWorkbooks
  • FREE workbooks
  • Free-Downloads-Teachers
  • Fun way to write definitions
  • GA Henty books by time period to read online or download
  • Half-Size Nature Journal
  • Hand writing work sheets
  • Home School Share
  • Home schooling library
  • Homeschool Planner
  • Homeschool World: Contests for Homeschoolers
  • Homeschoolshare
  • ICE FreeBooks
  • If it's not free it's not for me
  • Itsy Bitsy Books
  • Joy of Baking
  • Jumpstart-Worksheets
  • K-12 Student Interactives
  • Learn how to draw
  • Learn to Read
  • Learner's Library
  • Learning Island
  • Learning Page
  • Learning styles Questionnaire
  • Lesson Corner Puzzle Makers
  • Lesson Plans
  • LibriVox – free audiobooks
  • Links-heaps of them
  • Maps
  • Maps-clear and printable
  • Math Games-Free Printable
  • Math Worksheets
  • Maths curriculum including resources posters..games etc
  • Mr Printables
  • Multiplication-interactive games
  • Music games from N York philharmonic
  • myhomelearning-game directory
  • Nature Journal
  • Nature Journal – Half-Sized
  • Nature Journal – Printable Files
  • Nature journalling booklet 16 pages
  • Nature Journals – the how and why
  • Newseum – todays front pages USA only
  • Notebooking – Science & Nature Pages
  • Notebooking pages
  • Outdoor hour – check the side bar for heaps of links and ideas
  • PBS Learning Media
  • Playful Learning
  • Playfulearning
  • Printable booklets
  • Read me resources
  • Reading assessment workbook for younger kids
  • Science Experiments and Science Projects
  • Science resources
  • Sewing
  • Smithsonian Education – Introduction to the Nature Journal
  • Sparkle box 2 UK
  • Sparkle box NZ
  • Start a Nature Notebook
  • Summer (and Beyond!) with a Nature Notebook
  • Super teacher worksheets
  • Superteacherworksheet
  • Teacher created materials
  • Teachers' Pet
  • Teaching Good Things
  • Thematic Units, eWorkbooks,
  • Twinkl
  • Unit studies by grade
  • Work Sheet
  • World History
  • Xtramath
  • Young Novelist Workbooks
  • Your child learns: Geography
  • Yr 1-10 Resources and NCEA 1-3
  • zFree Stuff For Homeschoolers

zHealth

  • 56 fermented recipes
  • Cancer
  • Cancer Outside the Box
  • Cancer Truth
  • Water Cure
Follow Me on Pinterest
Homeschool Domination
Created by: College At Home
©2023 Home Education Foundation | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes